There’s a Riot Goin’ On Album Review: Sly Stone’s Dark Turn

Six months after Marvin Gaye asked what was going on, Sly Stone answered with an album that sounded as if the question had already been settled, and not in anyone’s favour. There’s a Riot Goin’ On, released by Epic in November 1971, is the record where the most joyful band in America turned the lights down and stopped pretending. Fifty-five years on, There’s a Riot Goin’ On album still splits listeners, and that division is the best argument for hearing it properly.

This is not an easy record, and it was never meant to be. It is murky, slow, often barely audible, and it went straight to number one on both the Billboard 200 and the soul albums chart. That combination tells you something about where black America, and pop music, stood at the start of the seventies.

From Woodstock to a Bel Air loft

In 1969 Sly and the Family Stone were the most exciting live act in the country. Stand! had made them stars, Woodstock had made them legends, and “Thank You (Falettinme Be Mice Elf Agin)” topped the Hot 100 early in 1970. The band was integrated, mixed-gender and built on the idea that everybody could get on the same groove.

Then the groove stopped. Sly moved to Los Angeles, the drug use deepened, gigs were missed, and Epic waited more than two years for a new studio album. When it came, it had been assembled largely by one man: Sly working at the Record Plant in Sausalito and in a home studio in the loft of his Bel Air house, overdubbing, erasing and re-recording parts through 1970 and 1971. The working title was Africa Talks to You. It changed after What’s Going On appeared in May 1971, and the new title reads like a deliberately bleak reply.

How There’s a Riot Goin’ On album was made

The sound is inseparable from the way it was put together. Sly played much of it himself: bass, guitar, keyboards and a good share of the drums. The rhythmic backbone of several tracks is a Maestro Rhythm King MRK-2, an early drum machine sold as a home organ accompaniment. Sly found its presets stiff, so he programmed and overdubbed around them, and the result is a pulse that feels both mechanical and oddly human, like a heartbeat heard through a wall.

The tapes were worked so hard that the mix ended up thick and smeared. Vocals sit inside the music rather than on top of it, and many lyrics are genuinely difficult to make out. Several female backing vocalists were largely mixed away. The Family Stone are still present, among them Rose Stone on vocals and keys, Jerry Martini on tenor, Cynthia Robinson on trumpet, Freddie Stone on guitar and Larry Graham on bass, alongside drummers Greg Errico and Gerry Gibson. But they often sound like visitors to Sly’s private session rather than the engine of it. Guests drift through too: Billy Preston on keyboards, with Bobby Womack and Ike Turner credited on guitar.

It is worth stressing that the murk is part of the music, not a failure of it. Next to the bright, tightly drilled Stax productions on Otis Blue, Riot sounds almost unfinished. That is the point. The record sounds like the inside of a closed room.

The There’s a Riot Goin’ On album, track by track

“Luv n’ Haight” and “Just Like a Baby”

The opener sets the tone with a groove that wants to party and a vocal that cannot quite commit to it: “feel so good, don’t want to move”. “Just Like a Baby” is slower still, over five minutes of slurred, woozy soul that sounds like it is being played at the wrong speed even when it isn’t.

“Family Affair”

The hit, and one of the strangest number ones in American history. Built on the Rhythm King, a soft electric piano and Sly’s half-whispered lead, with Rose Stone answering him, it spent three weeks at the top of the Hot 100 and also went to number one R&B. The lyric is about the ties you cannot cut, and the delivery has none of the uplift of “Everyday People”. It is a love song to family sung by someone who is exhausted by it.

“Africa Talks to You ‘The Asphalt Jungle'”

Nearly nine minutes of loose, circling funk that closes side one, and the clearest link between Riot and the long, hypnotic grooves of seventies funk that followed. Anyone who has dug through our essential funk 45s will hear where a lot of that sound learned to slow down.

The silent title track

The title song lasts zero seconds on the original LP listing and a few seconds of silence on CD. For years it was connected to the 1970 Grant Park disturbance in Chicago, where the band was blamed for a riot after a delayed show. Sly’s own explanation, given in 1997, was simpler: he felt there should be no riots. Either way, it is one of the best jokes ever played on an album sleeve.

“Runnin’ Away” and “Thank You for Talkin’ to Me Africa”

“Runnin’ Away” is the deceptive one: a perky horn line and a sing-song melody wrapped round a lyric about self-deception. It reached number 23 pop and number 17 in the UK. The closer then takes “Thank You (Falettinme Be Mice Elf Agin)”, the band’s celebratory 1970 hit, and slows it to a crawl over seven minutes. Turning your own anthem into a dirge is about as clear a statement of intent as soul music has produced.

The flag, the reception and the reputation

The sleeve of the There’s a Riot Goin’ On album replaced the stars of the American flag with suns and the blue field with black. Sly explained the colours as black for the absence of colour, white for all colours together and red for the blood everyone shares. In 1971 it was a provocation; it still reads as one.

The first reviews were mixed. Robert Hilburn at the Los Angeles Times found little to enjoy, and Greil Marcus described it as “Muzak with its finger on the trigger”, a line meant as a warning that now reads like praise. Time has been far kinder. Robert Christgau later gave it an A+, Pitchfork placed it fourth among the best albums of the 1970s, it entered the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1999 and it sits at number 82 in Rolling Stone’s 2020 list of the greatest albums. The record went platinum in 2001.

Its influence runs in two directions. Curtis Mayfield’s darker work of the early seventies shares its mood, as we noted in our ranking of the best Curtis Mayfield albums. And the bedroom-studio, drum-machine aesthetic pointed straight at Prince, at D’Angelo’s Voodoo and at every producer who has decided that a groove can be intimate rather than triumphant.

Is There’s a Riot Goin’ On album worth owning on vinyl?

Yes, with a caveat about expectations. This is not an audiophile showcase, and no pressing will make the mix sparkle, because sparkle was never on the tapes. What a good copy gives you is the depth inside the murk: the separation between the drum machine and the live kit, the space around the bass, the way Sly’s voice slides in and out of focus.

Original US Epic copies from 1971 are not rare, and decent clean examples turn up regularly in the second-hand bins; check the playing surface carefully, because a lot of copies were played hard. A 1986 reissue came with an alternative cover, and later CD editions from 2007 added four bonus tracks including the mono single mix of “Runnin’ Away” and the instrumental “My Gorilla Is My Butler”. The full track list and credits are documented on Wikipedia’s entry for the album.

If you are building a shelf of early seventies soul albums, There’s a Riot Goin’ On album belongs next to What’s Going On and Bill Withers’ Still Bill: three records made within two years that show how far the music had moved from the optimism of the sixties.

Verdict

Sly Stone made a party band’s record about the end of the party, and he made it sound exactly like that feels. There’s a Riot Goin’ On album is uncomfortable, self-absorbed and at times frustrating. It is also one of the most honest records in the soul canon, and the moment funk discovered it could be heavy without being loud. Play it late, play it whole, and do not expect it to cheer you up.

Questions listeners still ask about Riot

Why is the title track of There’s a Riot Goin’ On silent?

The track is listed at 0:00 on the original LP and runs a few seconds of silence on CD. Sly Stone said in 1997 that it had no running time because he felt there should be no riots.

Did Sly Stone use a drum machine on There’s a Riot Goin’ On?

Yes. On the There’s a Riot Goin’ On album he used a Maestro Rhythm King MRK-2 on several tracks, including “Family Affair”, and overdubbed his own drum parts around its presets. It is one of the earliest prominent uses of a drum machine on a major soul or funk album.

Which singles came from There’s a Riot Goin’ On?

Three: “Family Affair”, which reached number one pop and R&B in the US, “Runnin’ Away”, which made number 23 pop and number 17 in the UK, and “(You Caught Me) Smilin'”, which reached number 42 pop.